Free Workshop Replay

Marketing ROI: How to Know If Your Ads Are Actually Profitable

A 47-minute workshop on the numbers behind paid advertising: your true return after every direct cost, whether you get your money back in month one, and how to scale ad spend without breaking the business.

Presented by Alex Engar with Will Boyd · CEO Finance Academy · 47 minutes

The Short Answer

The ROI your marketer reports is usually revenue divided by ad spend. That isn't what you keep. To know if your ads are profitable, subtract ad spend, ad management, and every direct cost of fulfilling those sales, then divide what's left by ad spend. And check timing: if you don't collect more cash in the first month than you spent to get the customer, scaling your ads will drain your cash even if the long-term return looks great.

Direct cash flow from ads = Revenue from ads − Ad spend − Ad management − Direct costs
True ROI = Direct cash flow from ads ÷ Ad spend
Month-one test = Cash collected in month one > Ad spend + Direct costs

Why Your Marketer's ROI Isn't the Whole Story

This isn't a knock on marketers. Their job is to deliver leads and sales, and they only see that part of the business. Your job as the owner is to make the whole machine profitable, and that means counting what it costs to deliver what you sold.

Per $100 of revenue from adsWhat the marketer seesBusiness ABusiness B
Ad spend$33$33$33
Direct costsnot counted$70$20
Left over“3x ROI”−$3$47
True ROI3xLosing money1.4x

Both businesses get the same “3x” report from their marketer. One loses money on every sale. And what's left over still has to cover overhead and your own pay.

What counts as a direct cost

Any cost that comes with each new sale:

  • Materials or products, your cost of goods sold.
  • Direct labor, the people who deliver the service, like the clinician, the crew, or the contractor. Your front desk and office staff are overhead, not direct labor.
  • Sales commissions. If a rep earns 10%, that money isn't yours.
  • Franchise royalties that come off the top.
  • Card processing fees, often 2.5% to 3%.
  • Ad management, what you pay the person or agency running your ads.

Use a full month of numbers, and only count revenue that actually came from the ads. You may need to match sales in your payment processor or point-of-sale system back to the ads.

Check the tracking

One client's marketer was reporting a 5x to 7x true return, which looked too good to be true. We ran a small test, raising the budget by $500 to $1,000, and reported sales didn't change at all. An outside audit found the tracking was broken and was counting sales that never came from the ads. If the numbers look too good, test them.

Timing: Do You Get Your Money Back in Month One?

Imagine a true ROI of 5x, but the money comes in over 12 months. Spend $10,000 on ads, collect only $5,000 the first month, and the more you scale, the deeper the hole gets. We call that the sinking ship.

Month oneAmount
Cash collected from new customers$20,000
Ad spend−$10,000
Sales commission (10%)−$2,000
Cost to deliver−$3,000
Cash left in month one$5,000

Positive in month one means you've built a marketing machine you may be able to scale. Negative means you're funding growth from somewhere else.

How to collect cash sooner

  • Offer a paid-in-full discount. If customers pay over time, you're acting as their lender. A discount for paying up front gets you the cash now.
  • Shorten payment terms, from net 60 to net 30, for example.
  • Sell packages instead of sessions. A clinic can sell a six-visit package up front instead of charging visit by visit. An orthodontist might take $1,000 off a $5,000 treatment for paying in full.
  • Shorten payment plans, like three months instead of six.
  • Factoring lets you sell your receivables for cash now. It's expensive and best kept as a short-term option.

If you sell on payment plans, track the percentage of cash collected up front: cash collected at signing divided by the total sale. On a 12-month plan, that's only about 8%, which is very hard to scale on.

Before You Scale: Capacity and Your Path

First, make sure you can handle the leads. If you triple lead flow and your sales team or delivery team is already full, you'll break. Map how many more calls, jobs, or clients each team can take before you turn up the spend. Our Profitable Scaling workshop shows how.

Then map the path a customer takes and the conversion rate at each step. For a solar or roofing company it might be: door knocked, door answered, roof assessment, quote, insurance adjuster visit, signed contract. There are two ways to grow: put more into the top, or improve the conversion at each step. Raising show-up rate or close rate is often cheaper than buying more leads.

Three Rules for Scaling Ad Spend

1. Expect it to get more expensive

Your cost to acquire a customer will likely rise as you scale. If you plan around today's cost, your projections will be too rosy. Build some room in.

2. Watch one number, every day

Pick the one front-end metric that tells you whether the ads themselves are getting more expensive: cost per lead, cost per booked call, cost per appointment, or cost per sale. Track it daily, but judge it on a three-day or one-week average so one bad day doesn't send you into a panic.

3. Set a ceiling

Work backward through your conversion rates to find the most you can pay for a customer and still be cash-positive in month one. Translate that into a ceiling for your one metric. If it goes over, hit the brakes, test new ad creative, and reassess before you spend more.

Why profitable ads grow profit faster than revenue

Say a business does $100,000 a month, spends $10,000 on ads, and keeps $20,000 in profit. If it doubles to $200,000, ad spend may more than double, to about $25,000, and direct costs double too. But overhead doesn't have to double. If overhead stays roughly the same, profit could land around $35,000, close to twice as much. That's why we don't put much stock in rules like “spend 10% of revenue on marketing.” If your marketing is profitable in month one and you have the capacity, the question is how much you can scale it while keeping overhead steady.

“Test a lot until you figure out what works. And when you find something that works, the answer is often to do more of that thing rather than chase the new shiny thing.”

Alex Engar, from the workshop

What's in the Workshop

0:00Welcome: the finances of paid advertising
8:04Three steps to scaling ads profitably
10:06Step 1: know your capacity
12:06Step 2: find your true ROI
14:08Why the ROI your marketer reports isn't the whole story
16:08What counts as a direct cost
18:08The direct cash flow formula
20:11Calculating true ROI
22:11Step 3: timing and month-one cash
24:11Five ways to collect cash sooner
26:11Cash collected up front, and mapping your path
28:12Conversion at each step
30:13Rising costs, and the one metric to watch
32:15Setting your ceiling
38:17Q&A: which revenue to count
40:19Q&A: when reported ROI is too good to be true
42:21How much should you spend on ads?

Workshop Transcript

This is a lightly edited summary transcript of the teaching portion of the workshop, with example numbers in place of the specific figures discussed live.

Read the transcript

Why this matters

This isn't a workshop on what ads to run or what to post. It's purely the finances of knowing whether your paid marketing is working. If you're running paid ads, pull up your ads manager or whatever numbers your marketing company gives you and check them against what we cover. If you're not running ads yet, this is a great first step in making sure they're profitable long term.

So many owners tell us they're running paid marketing and have no idea if it's working. How are you going to scale that? One of the biggest profit levers is bringing in more customers. But if you don't know whether your marketing is profitable, you can't turn up the faucet on lead flow. Having profitable lead flow, knowing that if we put a certain amount into the machine we'll get a certain amount out, has been the linchpin of how fast we've been able to grow.

Imagine you're in an amazing car with a blindfold on. How confident are you pushing the gas? On the other side are owners with a million numbers and no idea what any of them mean. If an airplane is about to stall, you want the one warning that says push the nose down, not 500 other gauges. Today we'll focus on the numbers that matter. Our approach is calculated risk. I'm not going to put my family's future, or the families of our employees, in jeopardy, so we measure along the way.

Step 1: know your capacity

Do you have the team to sell and deliver on all the new leads? If you turn up the leads and get hammered, you can't fulfill. If you're a solo owner doing the sales and suddenly book 26 calls in a day, you break. Map capacity by department. Say three salespeople can take 10, 12, and 5 calls a week, and they have 8, 10, and 1. That's 8 open spots. Do the same for delivery. If you tripled tomorrow, could you deliver without hiring? Know which role is your next squeeze point. We've made hires too fast ourselves. It's an imperfect science, but you should have numbers behind it.

Step 2: find your true ROI

At 10,000 feet, ROI is how much you made divided by how much you spent. Make $100 on $33 and that's a 3x return. You'll hear marketing gurus brag about 27x or 8x returns. That's their advertising return. I guarantee they're not keeping all of it.

In reality, you put money into ads, it goes through your funnel, customers come out, and then you have direct costs to deliver to those customers. If the marketer says you spent $33 to make $100, but delivering it costs $70, you lost money. It's not their job to know that. Their job is to deliver leads or sales. Your job as CEO is to make the machine profitable.

Direct costs are every incremental cost of each new sale: materials or products, which is your cost of goods sold; direct labor, like the physical therapist delivering the visit, though not the front desk; sales commissions; franchise royalties; and payment processing at 2.5% or 3%. The formula: revenue from ads, minus ad spend, minus ad management, minus direct costs, equals your direct cash flow from ads. Use a month of data. Then true ROI is that direct cash flow divided by ad spend. If you spent $33 and kept $47, that's a 1.4x true return. You got your $33 back, covered your direct costs, and kept $47 toward overhead and profit.

Step 3: ROI timing

Imagine a true ROI of 5x, but you don't collect it for 12 months. Spend $10,000, make $50,000 someday, but only collect $5,000 up front. That's the sinking ship. We used to offer a six-month payment plan, and because of our acquisition cost, we lost money on each new client in month one. We could see it would be hard to scale.

Instead, you want cash collected in month one to be greater than ad spend plus direct costs. Collect $20,000 on $10,000 of ads, pay a 10% commission of $2,000 and $3,000 of fulfillment costs, and you have $5,000 left in month one. That's a machine you may be able to scale.

To collect sooner: offer a paid-in-full discount, because if you finance a customer you're the credit card company. Shorten payment terms from net 60 to net 30. Change how you package your offer, like a clinic selling a package that gets an outcome over six visits instead of charging per session. My orthodontist offered $1,000 off a $5,000 treatment for paying up front, and I took it. Shorten payment plans. And factoring, selling your receivables, is an option some businesses depend on, but it's expensive. Track percent of cash collected up front: cash collected divided by the total sale value. On a 12-month plan, that's one-twelfth, which isn't good.

Map your path

Map the path a customer takes through your pipeline. With a solar company, it was door knocked, door answered, roof assessment, quote, insurance adjuster, owner signs, then installation. What percentage converts at each step? As you scale, you can dump more in at the top, or improve conversion at each step. Show-up rate is a big one: you can book a ton of calls, but if only 10% show up, that doesn't work. If you don't know the steps and can't measure them, it's very hard to scale profitably.

Three rules

One, it will likely get more expensive as you scale. Your cost to acquire a customer will probably rise, so don't project at today's cost and assume it holds.

Two, pick one metric that tells you whether the ads themselves are getting more expensive. It might be cost per sale, cost per lead, cost per booked call, or cost per appointment. For us it turned out to be cost per qualified booked call, because we were getting unqualified people through. Get it reported every day, but look at a three-day or one-week average, because some days spike and you can't let your emotions swing with one number.

Three, define your ceiling. At some point acquisition gets so expensive it stops making sense. Work back through your pipeline: if I spend this much per booked call, and this percentage show up, and this percentage book a second call, and this percentage buy, what's my total cost to acquire a customer? That tells you the most you can pay at the front end. If you go past it, hit the brakes, retest ad creative, and reassess.

Q&A highlights

Are you using gross revenue or new revenue from the ads? New revenue from the ads. You may need to go into your payment processor or point-of-sale system to figure out which revenue came from ads. Whoever runs your ads should help you set up tracking that shows it.

What if the reported numbers look too good to be true? One client was getting a 5x to 7x true return on paper. We ran a small test, increasing the budget by $500 to $1,000, and reported sales didn't change. Either the ads weren't scalable or the tracking was wrong. Another marketing company audited it, and the tracking pixels were wrong and were reporting sales that didn't come from the ads. Most marketers focus on the creative side, not the metrics, and I say that as a former marketer.

How much should I spend on ads? It depends on your business. I don't believe the advice to spend 10% on marketing. Say you're at $100,000 of revenue with $10,000 of ads, and $20,000 of profit. Double to $200,000 and ads might go to $25,000, since it won't scale perfectly, and direct costs double. But overhead doesn't have to double. Profit might land around $35,000, nearly double. The opportunity is scaling as much as you can on the overhead you have. If your marketing isn't scalable yet, challenge yourself to make it so. And when you find something that works, do more of it before chasing new platforms.

Want to Know Your True Marketing ROI?

Our fractional CFOs dig into your ad spend, sales, and direct costs to find what your marketing really returns, set the one metric and ceiling to watch, and model how far you can scale it.

Book a Free Intro Call See our fractional CFO services

Frequently Asked Questions

Take the revenue that came from your ads over a month, subtract ad spend, what you pay to manage the ads, and every direct cost of delivering those sales, like materials, direct labor, commissions, royalties, and card fees. Divide what's left by your ad spend. That's your true ROI.

Most marketers report revenue divided by ad spend. That leaves out the cost of delivering what you sold, so a reported 3x return can still lose money. Tracking errors can also count sales that didn't come from the ads. If the numbers look too good, test a small budget increase and see whether sales actually move.

There isn't one right percentage. If your marketing is cash-positive in the first month, you have the capacity to deliver, and your cost per customer stays under your ceiling, it often makes sense to spend more. If it isn't profitable yet, fix the numbers before you scale. See our guide on how much to spend on marketing.

One you can pay and still collect more cash in the first month than you spent on ads and direct costs. Work backward from what a customer pays you up front and your conversion rate at each step to find your ceiling, then watch it as you scale, because it usually rises.

When your true ROI is positive, you're cash-positive in month one, your sales and delivery teams have room for more customers, and you're tracking a front-end cost metric daily with a ceiling you won't cross. Then increase spend in steps and watch that metric.

Keep Learning