A 90-minute workshop on figuring out what each employee really costs you, how much revenue they need to bring in to cover that cost, and what to do when the numbers don't work. It comes with the free Employee Profit Calculator we walk through live.
Free Google Sheet. Enter what one employee costs and what they bring in, and it shows your profit, cost margin, and how many clients or jobs they need to break even. Works best on a computer.
An employee breaks even when the gross profit from the work they do covers everything they cost you: their pay, payroll taxes, benefits, and their share of your overhead. To find that point you need three numbers: what you'll spend, what you'll make, and what you'll keep.
Break-even only means the employee isn't losing you money. What's left over after that still has to pay you as the owner, pay down debt, cover income taxes, and build reserves.
Wages or per-client pay, payroll taxes for W-2 employees, and per-person costs like health insurance, a 401(k) match, software seats, and workers' comp.
How many clients, jobs, visits, or orders this person can handle in a month, times what each one is worth on average.
What's left after their costs, their share of overhead, and the other direct costs of the work, like materials or card processing fees.
Divide your revenue by the number of clients, jobs, or visits over the same period. If you did $100,000 of revenue serving 50 clients, your average is $2,000 per client. Use 6 to 12 months of numbers so a busy or slow month doesn't throw it off. A roofer would use revenue divided by roofs installed. A clinic would use collections divided by visits.
Take your monthly overhead, not counting the pay of the people who deliver your work, and multiply it by the share of revenue this person generates. If four people deliver your service about equally and overhead is $100,000, each one carries about $25,000 of it. This is an estimate, and a rough one is fine.
The calculator counts the employee's pay separately, so the gross margin you enter should leave labor out. If your gross margin is 32% and direct labor eats about 15% of revenue, use 47%. If your only direct cost is a 3% card processing fee, use 97%.
Cost margin is the share of the revenue an employee brings in that goes back out to them in pay, payroll taxes, and benefits. It's the flip side of profit margin. These ranges don't include overhead.
| Cost margin | Return | What it usually means |
|---|---|---|
| 20% or less | 5x or more | Very profitable. Rare outside of materials-heavy businesses. |
| 20% to 40% | 2.5x to 5x | Workable and realistic for most service businesses. Healthcare roles often run 25% to 40%. |
| Over 40% | Under 2.5x | Hard to run a business on unless volume is high and overhead is very low |
A simple target: each person who delivers your service should bring in 2.5 to 4 times what they cost you.
An owner once told us a 70/30 revenue split with a provider meant they made money every time that provider worked. Once marketing, billing, and rent were added in, the business was losing money on every single visit. A split only tells you the cost margin. It doesn't tell you whether the role is profitable.
An attendee who runs a coaching company walked through one full-time coach's numbers live.
| Per month | Amount | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Revenue | $6,420 | 15 clients × $428 |
| Pay, payroll taxes, benefits | −$5,693 | $59,500 salary, W-2, plus benefits and insurance |
| Left before overhead | $727 | 89% cost margin |
| Share of overhead | −$300 | About a quarter of company overhead |
| Card processing (3%) | −$193 | Direct cost of the revenue |
| Profit from this role | $235 | About 4%, close to break-even |
The coach was barely covering their own cost, with almost nothing left for the owner. When a role looks like this, there are three levers:
Usually the easiest math. Most are paid 5% to 15% of what they sell, with 8% to 10% common. A great salesperson can be the highest paid person in the company, and that's fine if they drive the revenue.
The people who do the work or make the product. This is where the break-even math above matters most, and where most businesses lose money without noticing.
Usually a hire to buy back time. List your lowest value tasks, like email, scheduling, and data entry, and hand them off so you or a key person can spend that time on sales, leadership, or growth.
Start hiring when your current team is around 80% full and demand is trending up. Wait until you're slammed and you'll rush the hire, skip training, and risk the wrong fit. Hire too early and you're paying for capacity you can't fill, like building a 100-room hotel and filling 60 rooms a night.
“Debt is a bandaid, not a solution. Without any other changes, the cash-eating monster will keep eating through that cash.”
Alex Engar, from the workshopIf you've grown and you're now taking home less than before, you may be in what we call the profit valley. Lines of credit, cash advances, and putting your own money in can buy you time, but they don't fix it. The fix is usually in pricing, pay structure, what you sell, or cutting services and departments that lose money.
This is a lightly edited transcript of the teaching portion of the workshop. We removed attendee names, shortened the live back and forth, and summarized the spreadsheet walkthrough.
Alex: Today we're going to cover the core principles of profitable hiring, then walk through a tool that shows exactly how many clients an employee needs to see to break even, and how much each person really costs you once you factor in overhead and your other costs.
Will: Alex and I are both physical therapists originally. We started a marketing agency for physical therapy practices, and it took off. Then we had a couple of months in a row with our highest revenue ever and our lowest take-home pay. Our theory was that more new clients meant a better life for us as owners, and it turned out that wasn't true. We had great bookkeepers and a great accountant, but we could never get anyone to sit down and map out whether we could afford to hire, or how much we could afford to pay someone. So we spent about six months studying cash flow and margins. We started sharing what we learned with our agency clients, and some of them doing far more revenue than us said nobody had ever explained this to them. That's how we ended up doing financial coaching and fractional CFO work.
Alex: If you graph profit over time, early on when you're doing all the work with low overhead, it can feel pretty profitable. Then you crack marketing and sales, start hiring and scaling, and find you have less profit than when you were doing it yourself. Revenue might be higher than ever while your take-home pay is lower than ever. That's the profit valley, and it's where a lot of owners get stuck. To get out of it you have to master your numbers, balance the capacity you've built against the demand coming in, and cut some of the bloat that creeps in as you grow.
Imagine you built a hotel with 100 rooms, but you're only filling 60 a night. The instinct is to open a second hotel or hire 20 more front desk staff. Maybe you should fill the rooms you have first. The number one cost for most businesses is their people, so that's what we're focusing on today.
The goal is to solve the right problem at the right time, profitably. Think of your business as a pipe: leads go in the top and profit comes out the bottom. Somewhere in between is the bottleneck slowing things down. It might be marketing, if you don't have enough people coming in. It might be sales, if you have leads but aren't closing enough. It might be delivery, if you have a wait list and everyone is overworked. Or it might be admin, if there isn't enough management to oversee everything else.
The best time to solve a bottleneck is a little before you have the problem, but not too long before. A good rule of thumb is to start hiring when you're around 80% of capacity and the trend is up. If you wait until you're slammed, you'll rush the hire and may end up with the wrong culture or skill fit.
You're either hiring to buy back time, for yourself or a key person on your team, or you're hiring for profit. Hiring for time should still pay off in profit, because you spend the freed-up time on higher value work. Sort what you do into marketing, sales, delivery, and admin, and mark each task as high or low value. Then ask what it would cost to hand off the lowest value ones. Email and scheduling are the most common answers. A remote executive assistant has been one of the best investments we've ever made, and we've seen owners doing several million a year hire their first one and call it a superpower.
Salespeople are usually simple. Most make somewhere between 5% and 15% of what they sell, with 8% to 10% being common. A killer salesperson might even be the highest paid person in the company, and I'm okay with that if they're driving the revenue.
For delivery people, there are three numbers. What will I spend? That's wages, payroll taxes if they're W-2, and per-person costs like software seats, a 401(k) match, health insurance, and workers' comp. We also add two more: the share of overhead this person consumes, and the direct costs that come with the revenue they produce, like billing fees or materials.
For overhead, if you have four people delivering your service and $100,000 of overhead, not counting their wages, each one consumes about $25,000. It's an estimate. For direct costs, think in terms of gross margin without labor. If a roofer keeps 30% gross margin on a roof, but labor is 20% of that, the margin before labor is 50%.
What will I make? How many additional clients can this person serve, and what is each one worth on average? That's your average order value: revenue divided by the number of sales or clients over a period of time. If you made $100,000 serving 50 clients, that's $2,000 per client. In healthcare, take what you billed last month divided by the number of visits. Use six months or a year if your sales vary a lot.
If you bring in $100,000 and it costs $25,000 to get there, profit is $75,000, a 75% margin. The flip side is cost margin: what it costs divided by what you make, 25% here. For employees, cost margin is easier to think about. Counting only wages, taxes, and benefits, 20% or less is hyper-profitable and rare, usually only in materials-heavy businesses. 20% to 40% is workable and realistic. In healthcare I see 25% to 40% as common. Above 40% gets much harder, depending on your volume and overhead. A simple target is a two-and-a-half to four times return on your direct employees.
A therapist once told me they had a 70/30 split with an employee and made money every time that employee worked. When we added marketing costs, billing costs, and rent, they were losing money on every patient.
If you're in the profit valley, you can self-finance with reserves for a while, float expenses on a credit card or line of credit, or take out a loan. If you've scaled bigger than ever and you're reaching for merchant cash advances, lines of credit, or a HELOC to survive, that's a bandaid, not a solution. It buys time, but it also adds a loan payment on top of everything else. Look at what actually needs to change: pay structures, payment terms with customers, pricing, or what you sell.
A core part of what we do with clients is look at the gross margin of everything they sell. Sometimes the lowest margin service is also the highest volume one. Sometimes we find a whole department losing money every month while another one carries the business. Those are hard decisions because they involve people, but if the business isn't working, everyone's livelihood is at stake.
Charlie Munger was famous for inversion: if I wanted a terrible business, what would I do? Ignore your numbers, never build reserves, and hire and grow without looking at profitability. Do the opposite of those three things.
Step one: choose how you measure the work, like clients, projects, visits, or orders, and the time frame, like per week or per month. Step two: enter how many this person can handle and the average revenue for each, plus a cancellation or no-show rate if that applies to you. Step three: enter their cost. Choose W-2 or 1099, then enter either a yearly salary or a per-client rate. If you pay a percentage, multiply your revenue per client by that percentage. Then add monthly benefits and per-person costs.
In our live example, a coaching company owner had a coach serving 15 clients a month at $428 each, about $6,400 a month. Before overhead, the coach cost about $5,700 a month in salary, payroll taxes, and benefits, leaving about $727, an 89% cost margin. Adding about $300 for their share of overhead and a 3% card processing fee brought the all-in cost to about $6,185, leaving $235 of profit. Practically break-even. In a case like that, you either charge more, pay differently, or change the model so each coach can serve more clients.
What if I bill by the hour? Use hours as your unit and your average revenue per hour, or use projects and your average project value.
Our gross margin is 32%, including labor. What do I enter? Take labor out. If labor is about 15% of revenue, enter 47%, because the calculator already counts the employee's pay.
How do I figure overhead for one person? Start with your baseline overhead, minus the pay of the people who deliver the work: rent, admin, insurance, utilities. Then multiply it by the share of revenue that person generates. If you have 10 people who each produce about 10% of revenue, each one carries about 10% of overhead.
Has this changed a real decision? Last week a fast-growing client needed to buy back their own time but wasn't sure they could afford a key hire. The simple version of the numbers showed almost a three to one return. Then we asked what happens if the new person is only 70% busy during ramp-up. It wasn't ideal, but it was still profitable, and the owner had reserves to cover the gap. The owner went into salary negotiations confident the numbers would work.
Our fractional CFOs work out what every role costs and earns, model your next hire before you make it, and show you where pricing or pay needs to change. Let's look at your numbers together.
Book a Free Intro Call See our fractional CFO servicesAdd up everything the employee costs you each month: pay, payroll taxes, benefits, and their share of overhead. Then divide that by the gross profit from each client or job they handle, which is your average revenue per client times your gross margin before labor. The result is how many clients or jobs they need each month to cover their cost.
For people who deliver your service, a good target is 2.5 to 4 times what they cost you in pay, payroll taxes, and benefits. That works out to a cost margin of 25% to 40%. Below 2.5 times, it gets hard to cover overhead and still pay yourself.
It's the share of the revenue an employee brings in that goes back out to them as pay, payroll taxes, and benefits. If someone brings in $10,000 a month and costs you $3,000, their cost margin is 30%. 20% to 40% is a workable range for most service businesses.
Start with your monthly overhead, leaving out the pay of the people who deliver your work. Multiply it by the share of revenue the employee generates. If they produce about a quarter of your revenue, they carry about a quarter of your overhead. A rough estimate is fine.
A good rule of thumb is when your current team is around 80% busy and demand is trending up. Run the break-even numbers first, including what happens if the new person is only partly busy while they ramp up, and make sure you have reserves to cover that period.