Free Workshop Replay

Margins Masterclass: Gross Margin vs. Net Margin, Explained

A 31-minute workshop on what gross and net margins are, how to calculate them from your own profit and loss statement, and why a small change in your costs can make a big difference to what you keep.

Presented by Alex Engar · CEO Finance Academy · 31 minutes

Check your margins in 60 seconds

Enter a few numbers from your P&L and the free Profit Margin Checkup shows how your gross and net margins compare to businesses like yours.

Run the Checkup

The Short Answer

Profit is a dollar amount. Margin is a percentage. Gross margin tells you how much of every dollar you keep after the direct cost of delivering your product or service. Net margin tells you how much you keep after everything, including overhead.

Gross profit = Revenue − Cost of goods sold
Gross margin = Gross profit ÷ Revenue
Net profit = Revenue − Cost of goods sold − All other expenses
Net margin = Net profit ÷ Revenue

Cost of goods sold (COGS) is the cost to directly produce what you sell: materials, direct labor, subcontractors, and job costs like equipment rental. It doesn't include office staff, admin, or usually your own pay. Those belong in operating expenses.

A worked example

Here are the numbers from the construction company used in the workshop, for one month on an accrual basis.

LineAmountNotes
Revenue$208,000Top line of the P&L
Cost of goods sold−$27,000Materials, subcontractors, equipment rental
Gross profit$181,000Gross margin: 87%
Operating expenses−$69,000Overhead, admin, software, rent
Net profit$112,000Net margin: 54%

This was an unusually strong month, picked to show the math. Most construction and manufacturing businesses won't see margins like this on a regular basis.

What's a Healthy Gross Margin?

It depends on your industry, but here are the ranges we use as a rough guide.

Gross marginWhat it usually means
Under 30%Very hard to run a business unless you have very high volume
30% to 40%Tight. Every pricing and cost decision matters.
Around 50%Typical for many retail businesses
60% and upHealthy, and common in service businesses where materials are a small share of cost
Red flag

If your gross margin comes out a lot better than you expected, check your books. It often means materials or direct labor are sitting in the wrong place on your P&L, which makes your margins look better than they are and throws off your pricing and forecasts.

Why Cash and Accrual Books Show Different Margins

In the workshop, Alex showed the same construction company, for the same month, on both bases.

Same monthCash basisAccrual basis
Revenue$190,000$208,000
Gross profit$159,000$181,000
Net profit$90,000$112,000

Cash basis counts money when it hits or leaves your bank account. Accrual counts revenue when you earn it and costs when you incur them, so each job's revenue lines up with its costs. For measuring margins, accrual is more accurate, especially if your jobs or orders take months to fulfill. You can still file taxes on a cash basis and manage your business on accrual. Ask your CPA which method you file under.

Look at 6 to 12 Months, Not One Month

A manufacturing client's monthly gross margins in the workshop went 58%, 43%, 70%, 23%, and 47%. Net profit seesawed the same way: big orders came in, then the cost of filling them hit the next month. Judge your margins month by month and you're on an emotional roller coaster.

  • Use at least 6 months of data, and 12 months if you have it. A full year covers your busy and slow seasons.
  • Don't go much past 12 months. Prices and wages have changed so much that older numbers can mislead you.
  • Still look every month, but make decisions on the longer trend.

Why a Small Change in Costs Has a Big Effect

Every dollar you save in cost of goods drops straight to your bottom line. Here is the example from the workshop, for every $100 of revenue.

Per $100 of revenueBeforeAfter
Cost of goods sold$60$57
Gross profit$40$43
Operating expenses$35$35
Net profit$5$8

Cutting cost of goods by 5% raised net profit by 60%. Your numbers will be different, but the point holds: be intentional about your expenses and keep a close eye on your cost of goods, and the bottom line moves much faster than the top line does.

“Five percent change up here brought me a sixty percent increase down here.”

Alex Engar, from the workshop

What's in the Workshop

0:00Welcome and what you'll learn
2:04Common money problems owners face as they scale
4:07Profit vs. margin
5:08Gross profit and cost of goods sold
8:11How to calculate gross margin
9:12What a healthy gross margin looks like
11:14Same month, different numbers: cash vs. accrual
13:17Why monthly margins swing so much
14:20Net profit, and why it isn't cash
17:22How to calculate net margin
19:25The net income seesaw in construction and manufacturing
22:27How a 5% cost cut grows net profit 60%
27:36Q&A: should you use cash or accrual?
29:39Q&A: debt payments and inflation

Workshop Transcript

This is a lightly edited transcript of the teaching portion of the workshop. We removed attendee names and shortened some of the live back and forth.

Read the transcript

Introduction

Welcome to our margins masterclass. Today we're diving into how business margins really work: what they are, how you calculate them, and at the end, a resource for improving them. If you're watching the replay, grab a calculator and a profit and loss statement. It's best to have six months or a full year of P&L, so you can use the last 365 days or year to date. We'll get more accurate numbers that way, and we'll see why in a minute.

The goal is that you learn three things: what gross and net margins are, how to find them, and how to improve them.

Owners usually come to us in one of a few situations. They grew so fast they can hardly afford to pay themselves. They have a lot of revenue coming in but don't know where the money is going. Their P&L says they made a million dollars, and they can't find it. Or the worst one: they're the lowest paid employee in their own business. On the other side, we see owners who are doing really well but don't understand what's making it work. We want you to be an empowered owner who takes real ownership of the numbers.

My business partner Will and I are both former physical therapists, so we approach finances like a diagnosis. We don't hand out painkillers. We sit down and figure out what's really causing the problem.

Profit vs. margin

There are two kinds of margins you need to understand, especially in a product or service business: gross margin and net margin. First, there's a big difference between profit and margin. Profit is a dollar amount. Margin is a percentage.

Gross profit and gross margin

At the top of your P&L you'll see income, then a line called cost of goods sold, often called COGS. If you sell a product or have people directly fulfilling a product or service, you'll have this line. Some service businesses, like a physical therapy practice, might show zero there.

COGS usually falls into two categories: the materials you use to build the product, and direct labor, the people who actually perform the service or build the product. Not admin labor, not office labor, and usually not your own labor as the owner.

Income minus COGS equals gross profit, which is a dollar amount. In a construction business, COGS might include blueprints, equipment rental, job materials, and subcontractors. In this example, $190,000 of income minus about $30,000 of COGS gives us $159,000 of gross profit.

A quick hint: if you don't see your materials and labor listed in COGS, talk to your bookkeeper. When I sit down with owners and we calculate their gross margin, a lot of times they say it looks way better than they thought. That's a red flag. It usually means the bookkeeper isn't breaking these costs out right, and that means you can't make correct decisions or projections.

Gross margin is gross profit divided by total income. In other words, what percentage of my money do I keep after all my direct costs? In the construction example, $159,000 divided by $190,000 is 84%, which is ridiculously good.

It gets really hard to run a business if your gross margin is much less than about 30%. You have to be a very high volume business to make that work. Many retail businesses hover around 50%. Once you get much below 40%, it starts to get pretty hard. In the product business example, $56,000 of gross profit on $71,000 of revenue is a 79% margin. Very healthy.

Cash vs. accrual

Look at these two reports. Same business, same month. One shows $190,000 of revenue, the other shows $208,000. Gross profit is $159,000 on one and $181,000 on the other. Net is $90,000 on one and $112,000 on the other. The difference is that one is cash basis and the other is accrual basis.

If you sell a product, or your fulfillment cycle takes months or even a year like it does in construction, you need to be careful about which books you're looking at. That's a $20,000 difference. For calculating margins, accrual is more accurate. If you only see cash P&Ls, ask your bookkeeper or accountant. Which one you report to the IRS is a tax question.

Why monthly margins swing

Here's a manufacturing business with gross margin calculated month by month. Is the margin 58%? 43%? 70%? 23%? 47%? When I graph it, it's a roller coaster, both financially and emotionally. So I don't lean heavily on month-by-month gross margins, especially in a business like this. Instead I look at totals over time. Use at least six months of data, and 12 months is even better, because a full year covers the seasonality in your business. I don't like going back much more than 12 months, though, because inflation has changed pricing so much that older margins can look totally different.

Net profit and net margin

Net profit is income minus cost of goods minus all your other expenses. It's what you keep at the end of the day, and it's what you're taxed on if you run an LLC or S corp. Net profit is not the same as cash in the bank, but it's a really important number to understand and know how to affect. On the P&L it's called net income, the bottom line.

Net margin is net profit divided by income. Out of all the money I made, what percentage did I keep? In the construction example, $90,000 of net profit on $190,000 of revenue is 47%. That's not sustainable for almost any business unless you're an online business with very little overhead. Full disclosure, I just happened to pick a good month. A brick and mortar or manufacturing business won't hit that regularly.

I don't know why bookkeepers don't put these percentages in their reports. We build dashboards that show net and gross margin at a glance every month, how they're changing quarter to quarter, and how they compare to last year, so you can see the story of what's going on in your business.

The seesaw

Zoom in on the manufacturing company's net income and you see a seesaw. It's very common in construction and manufacturing. Big orders come in, revenue and net income go up, then they fulfill the work and it drops. The goal is to smooth that out so you don't pay yourself a lot one month and nothing the next. We find the level where you can take a consistent paycheck every month, then at the end of each quarter take an owner's bonus from the extra. That consistency was a big part of my family buying in to me going full-time in the business, and the bank liked seeing it when we applied for a construction loan for our house.

Why small cost changes matter

Say for every $100 of income you have $60 of cost of goods. That's $40 of gross profit, a 40% gross margin. Then you have $35 of expenses, which leaves $5. That's a 5% net margin. Now drop cost of goods from $60 to $57. That's a 5% change in cost of goods, and every dollar of it goes straight to the bottom line. Net profit goes from $5 to $8, a 60% increase. Did I pick these numbers to make the point? A little. But the point is real: be intentional with your expenses, control your cost of goods, and the bottom line moves a lot.

Q&A highlights

Should I use cash or accrual? For taxes, ask your accountant. For managing the business, if every order you take lines up with costs going out for that customer, accrual usually makes the most sense. If money comes in months before the costs go out, or the other way around, cash basis won't tell you much. I have owners who file taxes on cash but make business decisions on accrual. The larger you get, the more likely you'll need accrual, and past certain thresholds it's required.

If there's debt, does the P&L include principal and interest, or just interest? Interest only. Debt principal payments never go on the P&L.

How do you compare margins with inflation? It gets sticky. Costs have exploded over the past few years, especially wages. If you compare this year to last year you'll see you're paying more, and the cost to hire good people has gone up too. That's another reason not to compare against data much older than 12 months.

Want Someone to Run These Numbers With You?

Our fractional CFOs look at your margins every month, find where money is leaking, and help you make pricing and cost decisions with real numbers. Let's look at yours together.

Book a Free Intro Call See our fractional CFO services

Frequently Asked Questions

Gross margin is the percentage of revenue you keep after the direct costs of delivering your product or service, like materials and direct labor. Net margin is the percentage you keep after all expenses, including overhead. Gross margin shows whether your pricing and job costs work. Net margin shows whether the whole business is profitable.

Subtract cost of goods sold from revenue to get gross profit, then divide gross profit by revenue. For example, $190,000 of revenue minus $31,000 of cost of goods is $159,000 of gross profit, and $159,000 divided by $190,000 is an 84% gross margin. Use 6 to 12 months of numbers for an accurate picture.

It varies by industry. Below about 30% it's very hard to run a business without high volume, and below 40% things get tight. Many retail businesses run around 50%, and service businesses are often 60% or higher. Compare yourself to businesses in your own industry, like our benchmarks for HVAC, plumbing, and roofing companies.

Accrual is more accurate for margins because it matches revenue with the costs of earning it. That matters most when jobs or orders take months to complete. Many owners file taxes on a cash basis and still manage the business on accrual reports. Ask your CPA which method you file under.

Usually because revenue and the costs of earning it land in different months, especially on cash-basis books or with big orders and long jobs. Seasonality adds to it. Look at 6 to 12 months together instead of reacting to a single month, and check that your bookkeeper is putting materials and direct labor in cost of goods sold.

Keep Learning