A 37-minute workshop that walks line by line through your profit and loss statement and balance sheet to catch the bookkeeping mistakes that cost owners money, trigger IRS questions, and make it hard to get a loan.
Free Google Doc with every check from the workshop. Open your P&L and balance sheet next to it and work down the list.
Your books are your responsibility, even with a great bookkeeper and CPA, because you're the one who signs the tax return. Once a month, spend a few minutes checking the handful of places mistakes usually hide: revenue that's really a transfer or sales tax, personal payments counted as business expenses, missing bank or credit card accounts, wrong balances, and numbers that changed after the month was closed.
After we spotted a number that looked off in one client's books, they raised rates on one part of the business, a change they expected to add about $100,000 to revenue over the next year.
We found a $19,000 personal federal tax payment recorded as a business expense, missed by a bookkeeper who was also a CPA. Left alone, it would have looked like a $36,000 write-off by year end.
Alex once double-counted revenue after setting up a new company structure and overpaid about $22,000 in taxes before catching it. Another client double-counted revenue for years because transfers between accounts were recorded as sales.
Banks want clean, consistent financials for business loans, and for personal ones too. A construction loan for a home is one of the hardest to get as an owner without them.
Your bookkeeper may send you accrual-basis reports while your CPA files your taxes on a cash basis. Check which method you actually file under, and review your books on that basis.
The balance sheet is where we find the most mistakes, and the one most owners never look at.
“I love bookkeepers to death, while verifying that the work they do is accurate.”
Alex Engar, from the workshopAsk your CPA how to classify them for taxes. For running the business, if a contractor does the actual delivery work, like a roofer on the roof or a teacher running the class you sell, treat their cost as cost of goods. If they do admin or office work, it's overhead. The estimator, the office staff, and the owner aren't cost of goods.
This is a lightly edited transcript of the teaching portion of the workshop. We removed attendee names and shortened some of the live back and forth.
Welcome to the Better Books workshop. Today you'll learn how to make sure your books are clean, so you can make better decisions, avoid overpaying on taxes, and become bankable as a business owner.
First principle: responsibility. As owners we want to delegate everything. But your books are your responsibility, because your money is your responsibility. If a client had a poor experience because of an employee, that's still on you. In the same way, even if, and especially if, you have a bookkeeper and an accountant, you're the one reporting to the IRS what you made, and you sign off on it.
One, clean books show you where to focus. A couple of months ago we looked at a client's books, saw a number much lower than expected, and it pointed us straight to a profitability problem. After our next call, they sent a rate increase letter and said it should conservatively add $100,000 to revenue over the next year.
Two, avoiding an audit. In one set of books, within ten seconds I spotted a $19,000 federal tax payment sitting as an expense on the P&L. It was the owner's personal federal tax payment, paid through the business, and their bookkeeper, who was also their accountant, hadn't caught it. Not even halfway through the year, that was on pace to be a $40,000 write-off the IRS would never expect to see. I had to push back for about two months before they agreed it was a personal tax payment, not a business expense.
Three, not overpaying taxes, from missing expenses or double-counted revenue. I learned this the hard way. When I set up a new company structure, I didn't know how to guide the bookkeeper, and I double-counted a big chunk of revenue. I knew something was off with the taxes and pushed my tax preparer, who said it was right. About a year later I found it was a bookkeeping problem, not a tax problem, and I'd overpaid about $22,000 in taxes that I then had to amend to get back. Another client double-counted all their revenue for years: every transfer between bank accounts was counted as new revenue.
Four, becoming bankable. We just built a house, and without clean books we would not have qualified. Even with clean books, the documentation for a construction loan was a lot. You want to be bankable for both business and personal reasons.
This surprises me how often people have it wrong. Your bookkeeper might be sending you accrual-basis profit and loss statements, but what matters is how you file taxes. A lot of clients look at accrual reports all year, and then their accountant files on a cash basis. If you're a single-member LLC, look at the accounting method on Schedule C of your Form 1040. If you're an S corp, look at page 2 of your Form 1120-S. We've found several clients recently who thought they were accrual and were actually filing on cash.
Does total revenue for the year look accurate? Are sales broken out by category? A simple P&L has one line for sales, which doesn't tell you much. More advanced businesses break revenue into product categories, sometimes subcategories. Ask your bookkeeper to adjust your chart of accounts.
Has sales tax you collected been counted as revenue? One client's payment processor lumped sales tax into one deposit with sales, and the bookkeeper counted all of it as revenue, but didn't count the sales tax as an expense when it was paid. They were getting taxed on money that went straight to the government.
Have transfers been categorized as income? This happens all the time. Literally every month we catch it with someone. Go into your P&L in QuickBooks or whatever software you use, click on the revenue number, and scan the list. It takes 20 seconds.
Does your cost of goods look accurate, and are the categories right? There are some IRS rules on what counts, so ask your accountant. But if materials are hidden lower in your P&L as expenses, your gross margin looks great and throws off your decisions.
Are your expenses accurate? Just yesterday a client said their books were missing a lot of expenses, including rent. Rent slips through often, especially if the owner owns the building in another company and pays that company rent.
Are personal income tax payments included as an expense? Don't pay them from the business at all. If we hadn't caught it for that client, she'd have paid about $3,000 a month through the business for a year, about $36,000, the IRS would have disallowed it, and she'd have owed roughly $10,000 more plus penalties.
Is sales tax counted as an expense? If it's in revenue, it should be. If it's not in revenue, it shouldn't be.
Are owner distributions counted as an expense? I see this a lot when new bookkeepers or owners do the books. If you're a single-member LLC or a partnership, draws generally aren't a business write-off. If you're an S corp, your W-2 salary is an expense. Get tax advice on this.
I see profit and loss statements change over time. A bookkeeper closes January in February, and later goes back and makes a significant change without telling you. I've caught probably five in the last month. One bookkeeper overestimated income by about $50,000 in one month, changed it later, and never told the owners. Run a P&L by month and compare it to what you were told.
The balance sheet is the least understood financial report, and it's where I find the most mistakes. It's the first place I look in our reviews with clients.
Are all your bank accounts listed? If you opened a credit card three months ago and the bookkeeper doesn't know about it, none of those expenses are captured, and you're paying more in taxes. Are any personal accounts listed? Are the bank balances accurate? When a balance is wrong, the mistake can carry forward for years.
Are all your assets listed? One client had a lot of vehicles with loans, and none were on the balance sheet. If they're not there, your accountant can't depreciate them. We found six assets missing, worth thousands of dollars a year in tax savings. Do asset values match what you paid, not just the down payment? Have values changed between balance sheets? I've seen a truck's value change by $25,000 with no explanation. As owners we expect to delegate our books fully. In my experience, you love your bookkeeper while verifying their work.
Liabilities: are all your credit cards listed, and none of your personal ones? Are the balances accurate as of the report date? That's a snapshot, different from your statement balance, since the statement might close on the 12th. Are loan balances accurate, including any loans you've made to the business? These are most often wrong because the bookkeeper doesn't have access to your loan portals, so you have to send them updated balances.
Equity is the total you've taken out as an owner over the life of the business, not your W-2 salary. It might be called shareholder distributions, member activity, draws, or your capital account. It's usually a negative number. Does it look right? Did it change last month by what you actually took out? If it looks astronomically high, challenge it. And does net income on the balance sheet match year-to-date net income on your P&L? Those should match exactly.
Are 1099 subcontractors cost of goods or an expense? For taxes, ask your accountant. For decision making, if the person is doing the delivery work you sell, I treat them as cost of goods, because I'm selling their time. If they're on the administrative side, I treat them as overhead. On a roofing job, the roofers are cost of goods. The estimators, the office staff, and the owners aren't.
What if a teacher comes in to teach a class I sell? If the class is your product, I'd treat the teacher as cost of goods. If I charge $100 for a class and pay the teacher $20, I keep $80. That's gross margin.
Which bookkeeping software is best for a beginner? Most bookkeepers use QuickBooks. It's powerful but has a learning curve. Wave, Xero, and FreshBooks are simpler. Many clients on other platforms switch to QuickBooks as they grow. Once your books are complicated enough to need real software, it's worth looking at hiring a bookkeeper.
Our team handles bookkeeping and reviews your books every month as part of our fractional CFO work, so the numbers you make decisions on are right. Let's take a look at where yours stand.
Book a Free Intro Call See our bookkeeping servicesCheck the places mistakes usually hide. On the P&L, look for transfers or sales tax counted as revenue, personal payments or owner draws counted as expenses, and past months that changed after closing. On the balance sheet, make sure every bank account, credit card, asset, and loan is listed with the right balance, and that net income matches your P&L.
Transfers between your own accounts counted as revenue, sales tax counted as income, personal tax payments recorded as business expenses, missing bank or credit card accounts, wrong loan balances, and assets that never made it onto the balance sheet. Each one can mean overpaying taxes or making decisions on the wrong numbers.
Look at last year's tax return. A single-member LLC lists its accounting method at the top of Schedule C on Form 1040. An S corp lists it on page 2 of Form 1120-S. Your bookkeeper's reports may use a different basis than the one you file under, so check.
No. Pay yourself a distribution and pay personal income taxes from your personal account. When personal tax payments come out of the business, they often get recorded as business expenses, which understates your profit and can raise a red flag with the IRS.
When you keep finding the mistakes on this checklist, when reports arrive late or change after they're closed, or when you need forecasts and advice, not just records. See our guide on the 10 signs your business has outgrown your bookkeeper.